🎯🤖 AI & PR: WHEN DOES IT REALLY MAKE SENSE?
🎯🤖 AI & PR: WHEN DOES IT REALLY MAKE SENSE?
🤝 Resharing Peter Lawrey’s insights to clarify: AI can accelerate PRs, but engineering wisdom still does the hard work.
🔸 TL;DR
AI is great for PR when the change is simple, low‑risk, and easy to reverse. The harder part: spotting wrong assumptions, over‑complexity, or misaligned solutions; still needs human engineering judgment.
Original post: https://lnkd.in/p/eWyd93cx
1️⃣ [I use AI for much of the heavy lifting in research, trial solutions, mock systems, and development admin.]
AI fits best for PRs that package research, experiments, and boilerplate into something reviewable quickly.
#mock
2️⃣ [However, when AI produces a PR, I don't feel the need to hand-rewrite much of it; it's almost always a really simple change.]
Great use case: small, scoped PRs (typos, minor refactors, tiny features) where intent and impact are crystal clear.
#typo
3️⃣ [Gen AI is better than a developer for technology I have no expertise in, on a cost basis (e.g., per unit time).]
AI can draft PRs in unfamiliar stacks, but treat them like prototypes, not production code, especially for non‑trivial logic.
#unfamiliarTech
4️⃣ [But the result for anything non-trivial is usually a good start, usually works, but it is often a mess, or isn't fit for purpose.]
For complex PRs, AI is a starter, not a finisher; humans must simplify, align with requirements, and clean up the mess.
#complexityToFineTune
5️⃣ [The difficult part of engineering is frequently recognising that the approach is unnecessarily complicated, makes the wrong assumptions, or solves the wrong problem.]
PRs for critical paths, architecture, or subtle bugs need human judgment to catch wrong assumptions and over‑engineering.
#tradeoff
🔸 TAKEAWAYS
▪️ Use AI to speed up small, clear PRs, not to own critical architecture.
▪️ Let AI handle boilerplate; humans handle ambiguity and trade‑offs.
▪️ AI can kickstart work in unfamiliar tech, but don't deploy it blindly.
▪️ The real skill is recognising when AI’s solution is solving the wrong problem.
▪️ AI is a teammate for productivity, not a replacement for engineering thinking.
#CriticalSystems #EngineeringJudgment #ProblemSolving #TechLeadership #AIAndHumans
Go further with Java certification:
Java👇
https://bit.ly/javaOCP
Spring👇
https://bit.ly/2v7222
SpringBook👇
https://bit.ly/springtify
Java Fullstack Book👇
https://bit.ly/jfstack27